11:57A Hidden Coin Flip Steered These Experts' Decisions
1K views · 18h ago · 11:57
Fifty professional data analysts each worked with an AI agent (Claude Code, running Claude Opus 4.8) to tell a fictional farming co-op whether its advisory program should be expanded or shut down. Four of the analysis decisions had two defensible options. For every analyst, a hidden coin flip picked which option the agent would argue for. Its instructions told it never to misrepresent results and to change its mind if the evidence demanded it.
Topics: The Coin Behind the Advice · What Counts as Productivity? · Honest Advice, Assigned Opinions · 43 Minutes, One-Line Reversal · Whose Decision Was It? · Winning the Argument, Keeping the Influence













