Generation Why

Aaron & Justin · True Crime & Mystery · Unsolved Mysteries

Community rating

Read and write reviews

Apple Podcasts

Not on today's chart
Ratings on Apple Podcasts ↗

Spotify

Ratings only in the app
Open on Spotify ↗

Reddit

Summary below
What Reddit says ↗

YouTube

5.3Ksubscribers
YouTube channel ↗
Open the showWrite a review

One of the original true-crime podcasts, two friends discussing cases. Praised for a measured, long-running approach; production is modest.

Praised for

  • Balanced discussion, no sensationalism.
  • Huge archive.

Common criticisms

  • Modest production.
  • Some episodes slow.

Sources

Discussions on Reddit · reddit.comReviews on Apple Podcasts ↗Find on Spotify ↗

Summary written by The Pods from public discussion; it is not a quote. Last checked 2026-11-05.

Summaries are written by The Pods in its own words from public discussion; they are not quotes and not endorsements. Reddit threads belong to their authors. Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not make their star ratings available to other sites, so we link to them instead of copying them. The Pods has no affiliation with Reddit, Apple or Spotify. Own a show and disagree with a summary? Email hello@thepodatlas.com.